Skip to content

Mentimeter and Slido alternative for decisions

Published: Updated 4 min read

In short

Mentimeter and Slido are strong for polls, quizzes, word clouds and Q&A during a presentation. If you're looking for a Mentimeter alternative that brings a group to one supported decision, ConsensIQ is built for exactly that. The two types of tools can sit comfortably side by side in the same organisation.

Why people look for a Mentimeter alternative

Mentimeter has shown many organisations how easy it is to activate a room with a poll or a word cloud on screen. Slido does something similar, particularly strong for Q&A during conferences and panel discussions. Both tools are good at what they do: quick polling, gauging sentiment, collecting questions. But once a group doesn't just want to gauge an opinion, and instead needs to actually reach one decision out of several options, users run into the limits of a simple poll. That's when people start looking for a mentimeter alternative that goes beyond a single polling round.

This isn't a criticism of Mentimeter or Slido. A poll with a percentage per answer is exactly right for a quick read of the room. But a poll leaves no room to adjust preferences after discussion, and offers no process for narrowing five options down to one broadly supported choice.

The difference: polling versus choosing

Mentimeter and Slido are built to capture an opinion at a moment in time: who's in favour, who's against, which word rises to the top of the word cloud. That's valuable in presentations, training sessions and events. ConsensIQ is built around a different problem: how do you take a group from several options to one choice most people actually support? Instead of a single vote, participants spread points, say a hundred, across the options. After each round, the option with the least support drops out and those points are freed up to be spent again. That creates room to adjust after a good argument, something a regular poll doesn't offer.

Example question

Which theme should we pick for the annual event?

  • Sustainability and impact
  • Innovation and technology
  • Collaboration and connection
  • Growth and ambition

A poll gives one snapshot, ConsensIQ's point distribution shows which theme gets the broadest support after discussion.

When to use which tool

Choose Mentimeter or Slido, or a similar slido alternative, when you want to quickly gauge the mood, run a quiz, show a word cloud, or collect questions from the room during a presentation. Those are genuine strengths of these tools, no need to work around them. Choose ConsensIQ when the goal is to actually bring a group to one decision out of several options: a strategic choice, a priority list, a theme, a destination, how to shape a project. A simple yes or no voting tool often isn't enough there, because it offers no room for adjustment or ranking several options against each other.

In practice the two types of tools don't rule each other out. A team can use Mentimeter to gauge the mood at the start of a session, then bring in ConsensIQ later to actually decide between the ideas that were collected. ConsensIQ also runs on the same platform as PresentersWall, so presenting and deciding can happen within the same session.

See how a ConsensIQ session moves from options to a decision.

What ConsensIQ is, and isn't

ConsensIQ isn't a replacement for a quiz or a word cloud, and it doesn't claim to be. It isn't a broader voting tool with more question types, it's a different kind of process: built around spreading points and elimination rounds instead of a single vote. Participants join through a link or QR code, no app needed, and can take part anonymously. A facilitator runs the session remotely from a phone or tablet: starting rounds, freezing for discussion, adjusting options live. The result appears live on a presentation screen, with options growing as they gain more support.

See ConsensIQ's packages, from self-service to fully managed.

Is ConsensIQ a replacement for Mentimeter?

No, Mentimeter remains strong for polls, quizzes, word clouds and Q&A. ConsensIQ is built for a different process: going from several options to one supported decision.

Can you use Mentimeter or Slido alongside ConsensIQ?

Yes, many sessions combine both: first gauge the mood or collect questions, then use ConsensIQ to actually make the decision.

Is ConsensIQ a slido alternative for Q&A?

Not specifically, ConsensIQ isn't built for question and answer during a presentation. It's designed for decision making across several options.

Does ConsensIQ work hybrid, like Mentimeter?

Yes, ConsensIQ works in person, hybrid and online, with participants joining via a link or QR code and no app required.

Anyone looking for a mentimeter alternative for real decision making won't find a replacement for the poll in ConsensIQ, but a complement to it: a tool built for the moment a group doesn't just want to share an opinion, but wants to make a decision.

Book a no-obligation ConsensIQ demo

Together we know better

Tell us what you need to decide and how many people are involved. We'll show you in a short demo what that looks like in ConsensIQ.

Related articles

Ideas and formats

How to prioritise as a group

A practical overview of how to prioritise as a group: the 100 point method, dot voting, MoSCoW, and why elimination rounds genuinely help teams decide.

4 min read

How it works

Online voting in meetings

Online voting in meetings explained: how live voting works, when anonymous voting helps your group, and what to check for formal binding votes.

4 min read